Methodology
Changes and builds
The dataset build in use now is payauthors-2026-10-01-m64, built October 5, 2026. Every page, report and /api/health reads it from the same place.
Each paid report records the dataset build and analysis revision it was issued under, and each report version lists what changed from the one before. This page lists every build and revision, so a report can be traced to the data and rules behind it. Each dataset build is kept; the methodology describes the sources and rules.
Dataset builds
| Build | Built | What changed |
|---|---|---|
payauthors-2026-10-01-m64 in use | October 5, 2026 | Same catalogs. Records filed under a pen name that Copyright Office records tie to a legal name are matched again with the legal name added (held for a person to confirm); co-author index folded into the main index. |
payauthors-2026-10-01-m63 | October 1, 2026 | Same catalogs. Matching rule v6.3: translations, study guides, adaptations and disagreeing volume, issue or edition numbers are set aside. |
payauthors-2026-10-01-m62 | October 1, 2026 | Same catalogs. Registration matching rule v6.2 (precision fixes to title matching) and journal-article registrations. |
payauthors-2026-10-01 | October 1, 2026 | Added later Z-Library catalog records and the Internet Archive’s lending-library catalog (22,370,394 records in all). |
payauthors-2026-09-30 | September 30, 2026 | LibGen fiction catalogs parsed again (2,511,642 → 2,515,792 records). |
payauthors-2026-09-29 | September 29, 2026 | Added Z-Library records from the Pirate Library Mirror (PiLiMi) index and further LibGen non-fiction snapshots. |
payauthors-2026-09-26 | September 26, 2026 | First build: dated LibGen non-fiction and fiction catalog snapshots, the published Books3 file list, and U.S. Copyright Office TX registrations. |
Analysis revisions
An analysis revision changes how the frozen catalog results of a report are checked and counted. The same list is printed in each report’s notes and JSON. A report first issued under an earlier revision gets a new version when it is next opened.
| Revision | Date | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| Revision 37 | October 31, 2026 | Two changes. (1) Where a counted registration is not on the Bartz settlement Works List and the list appears to name another edition of the same work through a shared ISBN, the report now says what the tie is: the library copy we tie to the registration carries the ISBN the Works List gives for the listed entry (and, where it is also tied by title and author, that the two have the same main title and an author in common). Ties by title and author alone keep their wording. (2) A new section lists files in LibGen’s June 5, 2021 catalog whose records name no author, so a name search does not reach them, where our records tie the file to the searched author’s work by an ISBN of that work or by its exact title. The author is shown as added by PayAuthors from that tie; the catalog record is not changed. These files are listed for counsel to check and are not counted. Counts do not change. |
| Revision 36 | October 31, 2026 | The Bartz settlement Works List, as we hold it, now covers 482,416 of its 482,460 entries (looked up on the settlement site by Oct. 31, 2026); the number of entries we have not seen is now computed from these counts (it read 1,916 where the true figure was 381). For a counted registration that is not on the list, the report now says whether we can link another edition of the same work to the list: where no edition we can link by ISBN or by title and author is listed, it says so (and gives the record fact, such as a registration after Aug. 10, 2022, where one applies); where another edition appears to be listed, it names that entry, its Works List ISBN and whether it is on the opt-out list, and how the two are tied, for counsel to confirm. The report no longer says that a work not on the list was outside the settlement class; whether the settlement covers a work is for counsel to assess. Works List copies: copies in Anthropic’s download windows are added for about 4,280 entries that had none (including files under LibGen June 5, 2021 records that name no author, and five files added to LibGen June 5–17, 2021, in torrents made by June 19), 337 newly listed entries are added, ties through a placeholder ISBN (0123456789) are removed, and three file ties are corrected after a person’s check. Counts do not change. |
| Revision 35 | October 30, 2026 | Copyright Office renewals and notices of termination. The Registration Details report now lists, under each matched registration, any renewal and any notice of termination (17 U.S.C. §§ 203, 304), counter-notice or withdrawal that the Office’s January 2026 bulk files tie to it, by registration number or by the same title with a matching name, and the CSV adds renewals and termination_notices columns. 1,983 recorded-document links that the earlier build missed because the Office keyed the registration number in an unusual form (for example “TX00007646547” or “TX-7-626-997”) are added. |
| Revision 34 | October 24, 2026 | The catalog at each download. (1) A LibGen line counts for a download only if its file is in LibGen’s catalog in force then: the last catalog dated on or before the start of the download period, or one dated inside it (for a download known only by an outer bound, any catalog up to that bound). The test is on the file, so a record whose details LibGen edited still counts. In December 2015 LibGen gave 309 catalog IDs to other books; a line for an original file that LibGen no longer listed under any ID at a download is shown with that note and not counted for that download, and the later books under those IDs now show their own MD5. (2) A file line names a torrent only when that torrent’s own file list holds the file, and gives the torrent’s creation date; a torrent made after a download ended is marked so. A file that the archived torrent for its ID block does not list, or whose block torrent we hold no copy of, says so and names no torrent. (3) Works List copies: among copies in Anthropic’s download windows, one whose torrent existed by the end of that download is shown first, and a torrent made later is labeled as made after the download. |
| Revision 33 | October 23, 2026 | Changes for reports first issued under this revision. (1) The Bartz settlement Works List: the settlement site’s lookup now covers 480,014 of the list’s 482,460 entries (read through Oct. 23, 2026). Each counted registration says whether it is on the list as we hold it; a registration not found is marked so, with the note that the 2,446 entries we have not seen could include it. The list itself is not published. (2) A Works List ISBN listed for two or more registrations with the same registered title (a re-registration or new version of one work) is now used for matching; an ISBN listed for registrations of different titles is still not used. (3) Catalog corrections: matches missed because of spacing or punctuation in a title, and copies the Copyright Office record’s own ISBN ties to a registration, are restored for 236 registrations. (4) For a counted registration on the Works List, the report gives the listed copy we tie to the entry: the library’s ID and MD5, the torrent and its info hash, the pieces that carry the file and their SHA-1 hashes, and how many other files share those pieces; the opted-out works’ chain to the file uses it too. We tie entries to files from catalog records; Anthropic’s own copy and its hash come only from discovery. (5) Possible additional claims: a registration the report also counts says so, and a copy whose file is itself a Works List copy listed under another registration, or shares a torrent piece with a Works List copy, says that. (6) When the Bartz opt-out list lists the same title under another registration whose record names the same people, the report notes it; whether the two are the same work is not checked. (7) A catalog listing that combines several years, matched through the Works List ISBN, is labeled another printing or edition when any of its years is two or more after publication (the label only; it still counts). Copies found through the Works List ISBNs of the report’s registrations are looked for under other names too, and are checked like any other line. |
| Revision 32 | October 21, 2026 | Two changes, for reports first issued under this revision. (1) A catalog copy tied to a registration by title and author only (not matched on an ISBN, and no ISBN of its own on the Copyright Office record or given for the registration by the Bartz Works List) that names another edition than the record, or is dated two or more years after the registered edition was published, is shown as a possible other edition with the reason: listed, not counted as the registered edition, and not given a match carried from another copy of the same title. Later printings the Office record shows to be the original text (revisions 17 and 31) are unchanged. (2) A new section, Possible additional claims (more proof needed), lists the searched author’s registered works that are not on the Bartz settlement Works List as we hold it (or whose entry our review found names a different book) where a catalog copy in one of Anthropic’s download windows is a later printing, a later or revised edition, a possible other edition or a translation of the registered work. Such a work was never in the class, so the settlement did not release claims for it; each needs proof that the copy reproduces the registered text. Listed for counsel to assess; the section adds nothing to the report’s counts and confirms no claim. |
| Revision 31 | October 20, 2026 | Three matching changes, for reports first issued under this revision. (1) Later printings: a catalog copy dated more than two years after publication, with the exact registered title, whose Copyright Office record shows an original text (no new or excluded matter, no previous registration, no edition statement other than a first edition, the catalog author named plainly, and no translation, adaptation, introduction or editing) is shown as another printing or edition of the registered work. (2) Short titles: a catalog title that is the registration’s whole main title, two words or more, dated within a year of publication, under an author whose surname and first initial are on the record, matches a registration that adds a subtitle of four words or more (or a genre line), unless another registration with the same main title is on the line, or the record names a volume or part, or the subtitle names a grade, level, edition or companion product. (3) The Bartz settlement Works List: the settlement site’s lookup of 476,444 registrations (read Oct. 17–20, 2026) is used throughout. A catalog listing carrying the ISBN the Works List gives for a registration is matched to it; a match held for review is confirmed only when the copy also agrees with the Copyright Office record on its own (the registered title, an author’s surname on the record, English, dated no more than a year before publication; a copy two or more years later must carry the registered title exactly and is shown as another edition), never against a check for an introduction, translation, adaptation, contribution, edition, volume or companion book; Works List entries our review found to name a different book, a translation, a contribution or a shared ISBN are not used. A confirmed registration on the Works List says so in the report. |
| Revision 30 | October 16, 2026 | Anthropic’s download dates now use the days in its own interrogatory answer (Bartz, Dkt. 554-6: Books3 on or around Feb. 25, 2021; LibGen June 8–19, 2021; the Pirate Library Mirror July 8 to Aug. 10, 2022), with the registration-date cutoff the day before each window begins; the court’s order still gives only the months, so the days are marked as the company’s statement. A registration dated inside one of those windows now carries its own note: a possible claim, since whether the registration came before the copy was taken depends on the day the file was downloaded, which the company’s records would show in discovery; still not counted. A copy whose own catalog date falls inside such a window is shown there the same way. “Listed by the download” now means by the end of the download period. |
| Revision 29 | October 16, 2026 | Two matching changes. (1) A catalog author field that lists several people, each by surname and initials (“Carrell M.R., Heavrin Ch.”), on a listing already matched to a registration, is now read person by person, so a search for the full name finds it; such a listing is marked as listed under the surname and initials, unconfirmed, and is not counted unless the report holder includes it. (2) A catalog copy whose title names the same edition as the Copyright Office record (“Second Edition” and “2nd ed.”) and is dated one year before that edition’s publication is now confirmed by the automatic checks, as other copies dated a year before publication already were. Reports first issued under an earlier revision keep the earlier rule. |
| Revision 28 | October 15, 2026 | A report also looks up the ISBNs that tie its registrations to a book (printed on the Copyright Office record, given by the Bartz settlement Works List, or carried by a line matched to the registration) and adds catalog copies with the same main title that are listed under a misspelled or different name, or none; they are counted with the work, and the registration’s own checks still apply. A catalog author field that is a surname with a role, such as “Monteleone (editor)”, is now treated as the surname alone (shown, unconfirmed, not counted unless included). Lines built from the ISBN index now carry their catalog dates. The summary now names books whose only passing match is a registration match not yet checked. Found by the Whitley Strieber check, where an anthology was listed under its editor’s misspelled name. |
| Revision 27 | October 13, 2026 | A registration confirmed on one catalog listing is carried to other listings of the same title only where the other listing’s own date fits: a copy dated more than a year before the registered edition was published stays Not yet checked, and a copy dated more than two years after it is shown as another edition of the work, not the same edition. Found by checking every carried match in 109 reports; it can lower counts, never raise them. |
| Revision 26 | October 13, 2026 | Three changes. (1) When the searched name belongs to an author who died before 1931 (Open Library’s author record), what the author published in their lifetime is in the U.S. public domain, so a matched registration most likely covers only a later edition’s added material: unless its claimant carries the author’s surname, or it names a person with that surname born after the author died (such registrations stay counted), each stays in the report as evidence, labeled “Public-domain author”, and is left out of the counts and the registration-date screen. (2) The two late opt-outs the court allowed in the Bartz settlement (Dkt. 680 at 12–14), whose works are not on Ex. J, are treated as opted out like the works on Ex. J. (3) Where the record shows a company took only part of a library (DeepSeek’s 860,000 English e-books from Anna’s Archive; Anthropic’s PiLiMi copies of books it did not already have from LibGen; Meta’s partial LibGen download and its disputed Anna’s Archive torrenting), a line passing against that download says the library was taken in part and that whether this copy was taken is not shown. Counts change only for public-domain authors. |
| Revision 25 | October 11, 2026 | The rule of revision 24 now covers every book added from the author’s own book list, not only pieces in someone else’s book: when the Copyright Office record names the author neither as an author nor as a claimant (for example, a publisher registering the book as author and claimant, which usually means a work made for hire), the registration stays in the report as evidence, labeled “Registration found; it does not name the searched author”, and is left out of the counts and the registration-date screen. |
| Revision 24 | October 11, 2026 | A piece the author contributed to someone else’s book (an essay in an anthology or a chapter in an edited volume, added from the author’s own book list) is no longer counted on the collection’s registration when the Copyright Office record names the author neither as an author nor as a claimant: nothing on the record shows that it covers the author’s own piece. The registration stays in the report as evidence, labeled “Registration covers the collection”, and is left out of the counts and the registration-date screen. A registration of the piece itself, or a record that names the author, still counts. |
| Revision 23 | October 11, 2026 | A report now also takes in catalog copies found through the ISBNs that Open Library lists for works under the name searched, when the library’s record gives no author (or another name) and its title agrees with the work, as with an Internet Archive copy catalogued without an author. They are marked as found by ISBN and unconfirmed, and are left out of the counts until the report holder ticks them. |
| Revision 22 | October 11, 2026 | A company cannot have downloaded a library before it existed. Where a download is known only by an outer bound, the registration-date screen now starts it no earlier than the company’s founding, when that is later than the library itself: OpenAI (Dec. 11, 2015) for the “Books1/Books2” allegation, Perplexity (August 2022), xAI (Mar. 9, 2023) and DeepSeek (its lab, Apr. 14, 2023). Companies older than the libraries (Google, Apple, NVIDIA, Microsoft, Meta and others) are unchanged. |
| Revision 21 | October 11, 2026 | A Z-Library copy known only from the January 2025 catalog has no date added, but its ID shows it was added after Aug. 6, 2023. The registration-date screen now uses that date as the earliest it could have been copied; before, such a copy had no date at all, and a later download of the book by a company whose download date is unknown was listed as “dates overlap or download date unknown” even when every dated copy came after the registration. |
| Revision 20 | October 11, 2026 | The Bartz settlement’s lists are treated as context, not confirmation. A match that rests only on the ISBN the settlement’s Works List gives for a registration, or on the opt-out list’s pairing of a title with a registration, is no longer confirmed automatically; it is held for a person’s review and labeled “settlement only”. A catalog listing that gives two years (such as “1998;1994”) is read by its earliest year, and titles that differ only in spacing or punctuation now match. |
| Revision 19 | October 8, 2026 | A catalog listing whose ISBN is the one the Bartz settlement’s Works List gives for a registration (looked up on the settlement’s Works List Lookup) is matched to that registration and confirmed, even when the catalog title differs from the registered one, as with a multi-copy pack or a retitled printing. |
| Revision 18 | October 8, 2026 | A registration confirmed for one copy of a book is also shown on its other copies with the same title. When such a copy carries its own registration dated a year or more later, it is a later edition, and the carried registration is now labeled “Record matched: earlier edition” instead of “Record matched”, with the copy’s own registration labeled as covering what the new edition added. Both still count, and the registration-date screen still uses the earlier registration: copying a later edition copies the registered text it contains. Counts do not change. Applies to reports first issued under this revision. |
| Revision 17 | October 8, 2026 | The automatic checks now also read the Copyright Office’s full record for a matched registration: the rest of a registered title that the Office’s data cuts off at a colon, who wrote what, and whether the registration covers new matter, an adaptation or an edition of an older text. Titles that differ only by “&” and “and”, by a series or franchise name before the title, by the author’s name in the title or by a one- or two-letter typo, and catalog copies dated one year before publication, are now confirmed automatically when everything else agrees; a later printing of an original text is confirmed when the full record shows no new matter. Editions of public-domain texts, abridgments, adaptations, study guides and introduction-only registrations are held for review. For works on the Bartz v. Anthropic opt-out list, reports also list books that pass only against the download date agreed for that settlement (Aug. 10, 2022), apart from the actual download dates and not counted. Applies to reports first issued under this revision. |
| Revision 16 | October 6, 2026 | A registration that covers only something added to an existing text (an abridgment, a performance, an introduction, illustrations or notes, or work made for hire by someone other than the author) is no longer confirmed automatically; it is held for review. Recorded transfers and other recorded documents are listed under a registration only when the document belongs to it: about 4,200 links in the Copyright Office’s recordation file that cite a registration number for an unrelated title were removed, and each document now shows the title it lists. |
| Revision 15 | October 6, 2026 | Books of a series are no longer joined into one book because they share a series name, or a registration our matching found for several of their titles: “Skin Walkers: Mason” and “Skin Walkers: Taken”, or “Slave Ship” and “The Mandalorian Armor”, are now separate books, each tested against its own confirmed registration. A registration the Copyright Office record confirms for two titles still makes them one work, so a collection counts once. Catalog titles that begin with the author’s name are read without it. Book counts, the § 412 counts and Work IDs are recomputed. |
| Revision 14 | October 5, 2026 | The registration check now states confirmed matches as its figure; matches not yet confirmed are given as a separate number instead of in the denominator. The method notes describe the full-record check behind matches confirmed by main title. |
| Revision 13 | October 5, 2026 | Translations: a catalog copy in another language is no longer counted as the book’s presence in a dataset. It is listed as a translation with the registration of the original, and books found in a dataset only in translation are named under the § 412 table. A copy the library tags in another language that carries the English title and an English ISBN (or none) is counted as the book with a wrong language tag. Two titles that share only a subtitle are no longer joined as one book. |
| Revision 12 | October 5, 2026 | Books3: a book now counts as in Books3 only when a Books3 file name carries it. An edition whose ISBN is printed somewhere in the Books3 texts, with no Books3 file under the name, is shown as supporting evidence and is no longer counted in the date screen, the § 412 table or the company counts. Reports now show books per company and no dollar amounts. |
| Revision 11 | October 4, 2026 | One registration-date test for every part of a report. The § 412 table, the dollar maximums and each line’s date-screen mark now test a book as a whole: its earliest confirmed registration against the earliest date any copy of it in that company’s dataset could have been taken, and against the company’s first known download of it (revision 10). Before this, the table tested each title line on its own and the maximums did not apply revision 10, so the two could disagree. Books found only in another language, with no registration, are now named separately as likely translations instead of being counted as more books. |
| Revision 10 | October 4, 2026 | The registration-date screen now times each company against its earliest known download of a work. A later download by the same company counts only if the registration also came before that company’s first download of the same work (any copy, edition or format in the report), because § 412 runs from the start of a continuing infringement (Derek Andrew, Inc. v. Poof Apparel Corp., 528 F.3d 696 (9th Cir. 2008)). Counts against documented downloads look only at the company’s documented earlier downloads. This can lower, never raise, a report’s counts. |
| Revision 9 | October 4, 2026 | Three matching rules tightened. A catalog author that names an organization (a college, bureau or board) no longer matches on a shared word. A short catalog title is no longer confirmed automatically when the registration adds a subtitle, which often marks another book of a series; it goes to review. A registration for an edition published two or more years after the catalog copy is listed but not counted, because a revised edition’s registration covers only its new material. These apply to reports first issued under this revision or later. |
| Revision 8 | October 4, 2026 | Matches found only by main title, by title words or by publisher are no longer confirmed by the automatic checks alone; they are counted once a review confirms them (a catalog ISBN printed on the Office record still confirms them). This applies to reports first issued under this revision or later; reports issued earlier keep the earlier rule for these matches until a person reviews them. |
| Revision 7 | October 3, 2026 | OpenAI: the 2018 LibGen download is dated October–November 2018 as alleged (the date screen now counts from October 1, 2018, not January 1, 2018), and an alleged February 2021 download of Books3 (via The Pile) is added. Labels: court orders are labeled as orders, and Meta’s Books3 use is dated by its own LLaMA paper. |
| Revision 6 | October 3, 2026 | Counts, the date screen and dollar figures now use confirmed registration matches only; a match not yet checked is shown but not counted, and is double-checked when the report is opened. |
| Revision 5 | October 3, 2026 | Software review applied to a first random slice of the data (about 8,400 matches, each reviewed twice): matches the review confirms are marked, others found to be another work are removed, and a registration that covers only one edition’s added material (another person’s introduction, editing, illustrations, translation or adaptation, or a new edition of a public-domain classic) now matches only that edition. |
| Revision 4 | October 3, 2026 | Record checks updated: a catalog ISBN printed on the Office record now confirms the match; a different volume number now drops the registration from the line; the date window now runs from the publication date; the word “translation” in a book’s subject no longer counts as a translated edition; and matches decided in a software review against the Office record are applied. |
| Revision 3 | October 3, 2026 | Registration-scope check: a registration that excludes the searched author’s contribution, or registers a collective work by others, is kept as evidence but no longer counted; work counts and IDs recomputed. |
| Revision 2 | October 3, 2026 | One work ID per book, shared by the page, PDF, CSV and JSON. |
| Revision 1 | October 2, 2026 | Registration matching rule v6.3, the timing rule (download start or the library’s own record date, whichever is later) and the person check (a registration naming a different author with the same surname is left out). |
| Earlier | before October 2, 2026 | Reports generated before October 2, 2026 used earlier, unnumbered analysis. |
Site releases
Changes to how reports are issued, licensed or presented. Changes to wording that do not affect results are not listed.
| Date | What changed |
|---|---|
| October 31, 2026 | Works List: the lookup now covers 482,420 of the list’s 482,460 entries (4 more entries, looked up on the settlement site on Oct. 31), with their copies in Anthropic’s download windows. Fourteen registrations not on the list are no longer linked to a listed edition: a library catalog check found that the ISBN joining them belongs to a different book. |
| October 31, 2026 | Works List: the lookup now covers 482,416 of the list’s 482,460 entries (337 entries added, looked up on the settlement site from Oct. 27 to Oct. 31). Copies in Anthropic’s download windows are added for about 4,280 entries that had none, including files under LibGen June 5, 2021 records that name no author and five files added to LibGen June 5–17, 2021. Ties through a placeholder ISBN are removed. A counted registration not on the list now says whether another edition of the work appears to be listed (analysis revision 36). |
| October 27, 2026 | Catalog lines now show, next to each ISBN, the format, edition, publisher and date Open Library gives for it (for example: paperback, 2016), where Open Library has it. The discovery step names the torrent’s info hash and the records counsel can ask for: the matching magnet link, the .torrent file, and the torrent program’s records of when the torrent was added, finished and removed and what it uploaded. |
| October 27, 2026 | Works List evidence: 89 entries now also show their window copies of other editions of the same title and author (140 copies), listed after any copy of the registered edition, labeled “another edition of the same title and author, tied by an ISBN of that edition, not the registered one”. Each was checked by hand; 18 candidates that were a different book (another volume, a workbook, a study guide) were left out. |
| October 27, 2026 | Works List: the lookup now covers 482,079 of the list’s 482,460 entries (1,045 entries added, looked up on the settlement site from Oct. 23 to Oct. 27). 1,021 of them have a catalog copy; 1,013 have a copy in Anthropic’s download windows whose torrent existed by the end of the download. Their copies show their torrent pieces and the other files on those pieces, by the same rules as earlier entries. |
| October 27, 2026 | Works List evidence: copies tied to a Works List entry by title alone, through a catalog record that names no author, were checked against other records of the same file and of its ISBN. 623 such ties, where another record names a different author, are removed (13 entries lose their only copy, which was another book). 325 are confirmed by a record naming the Works List author and now read “tied by title and author”. The other 8,916, where no record names any author, now read “tied by title only (the catalog record names no author)” and are never shown ahead of a stronger copy. Home page: the third step now reads “Get your report”. |
| October 24, 2026 | Large reports now show Works List evidence for every registration that has it. Before, a report read at most 30 of the 1,000 parts of the Works List evidence store, and at most 8 to 12 parts of the file and torrent-piece lists, so a report with more than about 30 counted or opted-out registrations could show evidence for only some of them (in the largest report we checked, 33 of 212). A report’s files are now made one at a time when a version is issued. Report wording: “research support” is now “litigation support”. A report shows these from its next version. |
| October 24, 2026 | Works List evidence corrections, from a check of every Works List copy against the catalogs. 11,768 LibGen files that LibGen listed in its June 5, 2021 catalog under another version of their catalog record are now marked as listed then: 2,647 Works List entries that showed no copy in Anthropic’s download windows now show one, and 2,398 others show a different window copy first, by the usual copy order. 152 ties of a Works List entry to another book’s file are removed: 143 title-only matches to catalog records that name no author, where another record of the same file names a different author; six entries of one series whose shared ISBN pointed them at one title’s file; and three files under catalog IDs LibGen changed in December 2015 that still carried the earlier book’s registration. |
| October 24, 2026 | Works List: the lookup now covers 481,034 of the list’s 482,460 entries (490 entries added, looked up on the settlement site on Oct. 23). Their copies show their torrent pieces, the other files on those pieces and, for Anthropic’s download windows, whether the torrent existed by the end of the download, by the same rules as earlier entries. Five LibGen files that were listed twice in the Works List file index (under two catalog IDs) are now listed once, under all their Works List registrations. |
| October 24, 2026 | Analysis revision 34: each download is compared with LibGen’s catalog as it stood at that download, file by file. LibGen gave 309 catalog IDs to other books in December 2015; an original file under one of them that LibGen no longer listed at a download is shown with that note and not counted for it, and the later books now show their own MD5. A LibGen file line names a torrent only when the torrent’s own file list holds the file, gives the torrent’s creation date, and marks a torrent made after a download; a file the archived block torrent does not list, or whose block torrent we hold no copy of, says so. Works List copies prefer a torrent that existed by the end of Anthropic’s download. |
| October 23, 2026 | Works List: the lookup now covers 480,544 of the list’s 482,460 entries. Copies tied to the entries added on Oct. 23 now show their torrent pieces and the other files on those pieces. A file that its block’s torrent does not list no longer shows that torrent. Each copy’s tie is described more exactly: a tie by an ISBN on the Copyright Office record, or by title and publisher, is now named as such. A report shows these from its next version. |
| October 23, 2026 | Works List evidence: 21,293 Works List copies in LibGen torrent blocks that the Internet Archive and Wayback Machine captures missed (1,071 of them in the June 5, 2021 catalogs) now show their torrent and pieces, from Anna’s Archive’s copies of LibGen’s own complete block torrents, which match the captured copies wherever both exist. Each Works List copy now says how it is tied to the entry (by the Works List ISBN, or by title and author), a copy tied by ISBN is shown before one tied by title, and a copy outside Anthropic’s download windows is labeled so. A report shows these from its next version. |
| October 23, 2026 | Three download events added to the date screen: Together AI, whose own court answer says the RedPajama dataset it helped create held part of Books3 when released in April 2023; and Cerebras and Adobe, which authors allege trained models on Books3 through The Pile, SlimPajama or RedPajama (allegations). A report shows them from its next version. |
| October 14, 2026 | Report wording, in report versions issued from Oct. 14, 2026: a registration matched under a public-domain author is described as most likely covering only a later edition’s added material, with a pointer to the Office record; the dismissed claims against Guillaume Lample, Joelle Pineau and (in Sullivan) Mark Zuckerberg are noted; revision 27 is dated Oct. 13, 2026 (Central time). Once a version has been delivered, its files are never rebuilt; a version no one outside PayAuthors has received may be rebuilt under its number before delivery. The white paper was revised and retitled “Book catalog evidence in AI copyright cases”. |
| October 14, 2026 | Wording corrections; no result changes. The public-domain screen is described as a screen: a text first published after the author’s death can still be protected, and a registration in the name of the author’s estate stays counted. MD5 checksums and torrent details are described as given where the catalog and the archived torrents record them. The free check says what each count counts, and the list check carries the public-domain and shared-name notices. The evidence page’s “Possible claim” label is now “Passes the date screen”: one timing condition, not a claim. |
| October 13, 2026 | Each newly issued report version’s PDF hash is time-stamped by an independent RFC 3161 time-stamp authority, and earlier versions were time-stamped afterwards. Large reports (thousands of title lines) now build reliably. The free check notes when an author with the searched name died before 1931 (what they published in their lifetime is public domain in the U.S.) or when several authors share the name. |
| October 6, 2026 | Reports are issued as numbered versions. Each version’s PDF, CSV, notes and JSON are built once and never rebuilt; the report page lists every version with what changed and each file’s SHA-256, and payauthors.com/verify checks a file. Pages and reports name the dataset build from one source. Terms: the license covers the counsel, experts and agents a buyer retains; refund on request if the review lowers the counts. |