You’re signed up for e-mail updates.
Magistrate judge denies defendants' bid for artists' tax returns in Andersen v. Stability AI but orders a source-by-source account of their art income
Magistrate Judge Lisa J. Cisneros resolved two discovery disputes between the artist plaintiffs and Stability AI, Midjourney, Runway AI and DeviantArt. She denied without prejudice the defendants' requests for the plaintiffs' tax returns and 1099 forms for 2020-2025, choosing a less intrusive route: the plaintiffs must answer Runway's Interrogatory No. 9 in narrative form, stating art-related income source by source from Jan. 1, 2020 through 2025, rather than pointing to records under Rule 33(d). She granted in part the request for financial documents, ordering records since 2020 sufficient to show art-related sales and services, agreements for works the plaintiffs say exhibit their alleged trade dress, and related licenses, limited to agreements that arguably yielded earned income. She said such information is relevant because the plaintiffs may argue the defendants' products could cause wide-scale market harm in response to fair use defenses. She denied for now a request to reopen depositions. Order Resolving Discovery Dispute, Dkt. 784 (Nov. 16, 2026).
Loading the rest of the news…
What the labels mean
Every item says what kind of source it rests on. A court ruling or order is the court's own statement. A company filing is what a defendant says about itself. A government filing is a statement by a government agency that is not a party to the case, such as a statement of interest; it is the government's position, not a ruling. An allegation is what a complaint or motion claims and has not been decided. Reported means press reporting we have not confirmed from the primary document. Summaries are our own; follow the links for the source.
This page is general information, not legal advice. An allegation is not a finding. Whether any of this matters for a particular work or claim is a question for a lawyer.